{"report":"TradeOS case evidence","generated_at":"2026-11-16T15:56:24Z","case_id":"B-91C4EBFB15CF4467","environment":{"paypal_mode":"sandbox","note":"PayPal Sandbox only — no real money"},"summary":{"status":"REJECTED","decision":"REJECTED","human_decision":null,"approval_source":null,"refund_status":null},"paypal_ids":{"order_id":"3E194027XW0050439","capture_id":"5XY178711V964284J"},"refund_batches":[],"refund_api_called":false,"verification":{"ok":true,"case_id":"B-91C4EBFB15CF4467","entries":12,"broken_at":null,"reason":null,"head":"92324b51ee38ced676aa6819a3bddb8494ac2d72aa7325a9a2954563017bee9f","backfilled":0},"chain_head":"92324b51ee38ced676aa6819a3bddb8494ac2d72aa7325a9a2954563017bee9f","chain_entries":[{"seq":1,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:41:49Z","prev_hash":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","entry_hash":"bc7dc8e8ab95fe67509c9a55c6a3c2e6e42011e7ce0f0dc63e8de00714e3c55f","payload":{"status":"NEW"}},{"seq":2,"type":"paypal:create_order_with_card","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:03Z","prev_hash":"bc7dc8e8ab95fe67509c9a55c6a3c2e6e42011e7ce0f0dc63e8de00714e3c55f","entry_hash":"e11f7e26442ec6bf7166c876ef4e6743ef64a570ba0a9b51d50c36bfd33e26f9","payload":{"debug_id":"f633437dd3028","evidence":{"capture_id":"5XY178711V964284J","capture_status":"COMPLETED","id":"3E194027XW0050439","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"create_order_with_card","request_id":"tradeos-order-B-91C4EBFB15CF4467","result":"{\"id\": \"3E194027XW0050439\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":3,"type":"audit:payment","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:03Z","prev_hash":"e11f7e26442ec6bf7166c876ef4e6743ef64a570ba0a9b51d50c36bfd33e26f9","entry_hash":"d1293c4c6795c48a6d345b88e7d4adac108bacb1bd03c8d1b844aa7185d9ca4a","payload":{"detail":{"amount":"49.99 USD","order_id":"3E194027XW0050439","status":"COMPLETED"},"stage":"payment","title":"PayPal order created"}},{"seq":4,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:03Z","prev_hash":"d1293c4c6795c48a6d345b88e7d4adac108bacb1bd03c8d1b844aa7185d9ca4a","entry_hash":"8b4df4c98663d52768b6a2ae8e7ea5e3609d8e90adf9e5ab1ee4ff663d76fc7b","payload":{"capture_id":"5XY178711V964284J"}},{"seq":5,"type":"audit:payment","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:03Z","prev_hash":"8b4df4c98663d52768b6a2ae8e7ea5e3609d8e90adf9e5ab1ee4ff663d76fc7b","entry_hash":"53b7a77cbe4879d2e5c69ec2b8eb78195a86506cad1ac4e84ae25d1c00c4e0bf","payload":{"detail":{"capture_id":"5XY178711V964284J","order_id":"3E194027XW0050439","status":"COMPLETED"},"stage":"payment","title":"PayPal payment captured"}},{"seq":6,"type":"audit:request","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:03Z","prev_hash":"53b7a77cbe4879d2e5c69ec2b8eb78195a86506cad1ac4e84ae25d1c00c4e0bf","entry_hash":"f9b17664780d489d2404ca804d18494fa5e454edde5eb0dc34315175724e5d72","payload":{"detail":{"customer":"Tom (demo customer)","message":"The sneakers I received are black, but the photo shows white. The colour doesn't match the listing, and I'd like to return them for a refund."},"stage":"request","title":"Customer request received"}},{"seq":7,"type":"audit:intent","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:04Z","prev_hash":"f9b17664780d489d2404ca804d18494fa5e454edde5eb0dc34315175724e5d72","entry_hash":"dd6a3fafeccce6bd0a86b884d0b75da4fe23c3b7a6a83e75f1712308a1082aa5","payload":{"detail":{"assist":{"current_size":null,"language":"English","language_code":"en","merchant_summary_en":"Customer wants a refund because the sneakers received are black instead of white as shown in the listing.","requested_size":null},"assist_note":"Validated (information only; the policy engine ignores these fields).","extractor":"llm:openai/gpt-oss-20b","intent":"REFUND_REQUEST","note":"Validated against strict schema.","reason":"NOT_AS_DESCRIBED","requested_action":"REFUND","safety_gate":{"flagged":false,"rule_version":"safety-gate/3.4.0-main"}},"stage":"intent","title":"Intent extracted"}},{"seq":8,"type":"paypal:get_capture","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:04Z","prev_hash":"dd6a3fafeccce6bd0a86b884d0b75da4fe23c3b7a6a83e75f1712308a1082aa5","entry_hash":"7c53564ab4bb35895286c550020e35d72782fb8dc6122531ecfe0072be1e0154","payload":{"debug_id":"f558220721c53","evidence":{"amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"id":"5XY178711V964284J","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"get_capture","request_id":null,"result":"{\"id\": \"5XY178711V964284J\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":9,"type":"audit:policy","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:04Z","prev_hash":"7c53564ab4bb35895286c550020e35d72782fb8dc6122531ecfe0072be1e0154","entry_hash":"2d9677a54e9be555e9b07975bbc3297033b6e285785236245b5fcb78ff8d2ca7","payload":{"detail":{"action":"REFUND","checks":[{"detail":"Request understood as REFUND_REQUEST / REFUND (reason NOT_AS_DESCRIBED)","name":"request_supported","passed":true},{"detail":"PayPal capture status is COMPLETED","name":"payment_captured","passed":true},{"detail":"Purchased 45 days ago; window is 30 days — return window exceeded","name":"return_window","passed":false},{"detail":"Trail Runner sneakers, EU size 42 is eligible for return","name":"product_eligible","passed":true},{"detail":"Requested 49.99 USD; refundable 49.99 USD","name":"refundable_amount","passed":true}],"decision":"REJECTED","reasons":["Purchased 45 days ago; window is 30 days — return window exceeded"],"stage":"final"},"stage":"policy","title":"Policy pre-check: REJECTED"}},{"seq":10,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:04Z","prev_hash":"2d9677a54e9be555e9b07975bbc3297033b6e285785236245b5fcb78ff8d2ca7","entry_hash":"4328469bcb5190d2ec0814101196df6f17e33dfa679eeeb6177806e5761adf79","payload":{"decision":"REJECTED","status":"REJECTED"}},{"seq":11,"type":"audit:paypal","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:04Z","prev_hash":"4328469bcb5190d2ec0814101196df6f17e33dfa679eeeb6177806e5761adf79","entry_hash":"a59fd80d27dc0d9961f3529f60707a182f151f7d7b4c02fcd25a6cdf139e7509","payload":{"detail":{"reasons":["Purchased 45 days ago; window is 30 days — return window exceeded"],"refund_id":null},"stage":"paypal","title":"Refund API NOT CALLED — policy rejected the case"}},{"seq":12,"type":"audit:note","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:04Z","prev_hash":"a59fd80d27dc0d9961f3529f60707a182f151f7d7b4c02fcd25a6cdf139e7509","entry_hash":"92324b51ee38ced676aa6819a3bddb8494ac2d72aa7325a9a2954563017bee9f","payload":{"detail":{"generator":"template","language":"English","language_code":"en","outcome":"REJECTION_NOTE","source_en":"We're sorry, we can't approve your request: the 30-day return window has passed (purchased 45 days ago). No refund has been issued. Please reply if you have any questions.","text":"We're sorry, we can't approve your request: the 30-day return window has passed (purchased 45 days ago). No refund has been issued. Please reply if you have any questions.","validation":"English template."},"stage":"note","title":"Customer decision note drafted (no refund issued)"}}],"paypal_calls":[{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:03Z","operation":"create_order_with_card","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"3E194027XW0050439\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f633437dd3028","request_id":"tradeos-order-B-91C4EBFB15CF4467"},{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:04Z","operation":"get_capture","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"5XY178711V964284J\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f558220721c53","request_id":null}],"how_to_verify":"entry_hash = sha256(canonical_json({case_id, seq, type, ts, payload, prev_hash})); canonical_json = sorted keys, separators (',', ':'), UTF-8, ensure_ascii=False; entry 1 has prev_hash = 64 zeros. Record chain_head somewhere outside this server: tamper-evident, not tamper-proof."}