{"report":"TradeOS case evidence","generated_at":"2026-11-16T15:56:34Z","case_id":"F-089279C5C8904354","environment":{"paypal_mode":"sandbox","note":"PayPal Sandbox only — no real money"},"summary":{"status":"REFUND_COMPLETED","decision":"ELIGIBLE","human_decision":"APPROVED","approval_source":"human","refund_status":"COMPLETED"},"paypal_ids":{"order_id":"7S142334X2468105D","capture_id":"9M172932W5856520H","refund_id":"1LF75336ME8988949"},"refund_batches":[],"refund_api_called":true,"verification":{"ok":true,"case_id":"F-089279C5C8904354","entries":30,"broken_at":null,"reason":null,"head":"1abac4b13c6a41126bb5194afa0d8463878a12bc131a54f25d2dd1b595ee9436","backfilled":0},"chain_head":"1abac4b13c6a41126bb5194afa0d8463878a12bc131a54f25d2dd1b595ee9436","chain_entries":[{"seq":1,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:21Z","prev_hash":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","entry_hash":"7741aebbb9e389e96dfd111e3ff598c06a26e88b7b82bbc26d60af2682bebe96","payload":{"status":"NEW"}},{"seq":2,"type":"paypal:create_order_with_card","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:25Z","prev_hash":"7741aebbb9e389e96dfd111e3ff598c06a26e88b7b82bbc26d60af2682bebe96","entry_hash":"9eb27ab07b5806d0d4616d0088ede21faf2b6dd19324a462f48aa179a2e0a676","payload":{"debug_id":"f547983f3dfd5","evidence":{"capture_id":"9M172932W5856520H","capture_status":"COMPLETED","id":"7S142334X2468105D","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"create_order_with_card","request_id":"tradeos-order-F-089279C5C8904354","result":"{\"id\": \"7S142334X2468105D\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":3,"type":"audit:payment","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:25Z","prev_hash":"9eb27ab07b5806d0d4616d0088ede21faf2b6dd19324a462f48aa179a2e0a676","entry_hash":"d5666b597dd8cbaede61b02405caac6cdb8ee0f4765410ef2dba7d6426bfd1a5","payload":{"detail":{"amount":"49.99 USD","order_id":"7S142334X2468105D","status":"COMPLETED"},"stage":"payment","title":"PayPal order created"}},{"seq":4,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:25Z","prev_hash":"d5666b597dd8cbaede61b02405caac6cdb8ee0f4765410ef2dba7d6426bfd1a5","entry_hash":"012f507f15387062475e382fd5b5c10008a49d0b712188560412495397bd795d","payload":{"capture_id":"9M172932W5856520H"}},{"seq":5,"type":"audit:payment","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:25Z","prev_hash":"012f507f15387062475e382fd5b5c10008a49d0b712188560412495397bd795d","entry_hash":"f69fbcbaaf666cec57d88c23871f262d1228a065519d414ff5d38f0ce307c78a","payload":{"detail":{"capture_id":"9M172932W5856520H","order_id":"7S142334X2468105D","status":"COMPLETED"},"stage":"payment","title":"PayPal payment captured"}},{"seq":6,"type":"audit:request","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:25Z","prev_hash":"f69fbcbaaf666cec57d88c23871f262d1228a065519d414ff5d38f0ce307c78a","entry_hash":"39ab4faddca05d316fc461f6639c8ff08a385628947938789567d92a496d96bc","payload":{"detail":{"customer":"Free-text customer","message":"Hi, the running shoes I ordered arrived in the wrong colour. I want to return them for a full refund please."},"stage":"request","title":"Customer request received"}},{"seq":7,"type":"audit:intent","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:25Z","prev_hash":"39ab4faddca05d316fc461f6639c8ff08a385628947938789567d92a496d96bc","entry_hash":"5e0cb3e285f834996b0cee61c3de1c07ccfc1a0a2f5e0afa71f6021308bbdd48","payload":{"detail":{"assist":{"current_size":null,"language":"English","language_code":"en","merchant_summary_en":"Customer wants a full refund for shoes received in wrong colour.","requested_size":null},"assist_note":"Validated (information only; the policy engine ignores these fields).","extractor":"llm:openai/gpt-oss-20b","intent":"REFUND_REQUEST","note":"Validated against strict schema.","reason":"NOT_AS_DESCRIBED","requested_action":"REFUND","safety_gate":{"flagged":false,"rule_version":"safety-gate/3.4.0-main"}},"stage":"intent","title":"Intent extracted"}},{"seq":8,"type":"paypal:get_capture","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:26Z","prev_hash":"5e0cb3e285f834996b0cee61c3de1c07ccfc1a0a2f5e0afa71f6021308bbdd48","entry_hash":"4eec0fb56266df4bd1cece690cc1f83709756232ea2462caaf08895532a9aaf3","payload":{"debug_id":"f194143afc9c4","evidence":{"amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"id":"9M172932W5856520H","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"get_capture","request_id":null,"result":"{\"id\": \"9M172932W5856520H\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":9,"type":"audit:policy","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:26Z","prev_hash":"4eec0fb56266df4bd1cece690cc1f83709756232ea2462caaf08895532a9aaf3","entry_hash":"b38281a5bc45c75c8d743eaa11896b48d0b8f565397801b6d42966cf82add9d9","payload":{"detail":{"action":"REFUND","checks":[{"detail":"Request understood as REFUND_REQUEST / REFUND (reason NOT_AS_DESCRIBED)","name":"request_supported","passed":true},{"detail":"PayPal capture status is COMPLETED","name":"payment_captured","passed":true},{"detail":"Purchased 0 days ago; window is 30 days","name":"return_window","passed":true},{"detail":"Trail Runner sneakers, EU size 42 is eligible for return","name":"product_eligible","passed":true},{"detail":"Requested 49.99 USD; refundable 49.99 USD","name":"refundable_amount","passed":true}],"decision":"ELIGIBLE","reasons":[],"stage":"final"},"stage":"policy","title":"Policy pre-check: ELIGIBLE"}},{"seq":10,"type":"audit:policy","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:26Z","prev_hash":"b38281a5bc45c75c8d743eaa11896b48d0b8f565397801b6d42966cf82add9d9","entry_hash":"364e45e6d42212cb92faa6324e33d458db2c67b167ed8db1ad7e8d287f8c931a","payload":{"detail":{"action":"REFUND","checks":[{"detail":"Request understood as REFUND_REQUEST / REFUND (reason NOT_AS_DESCRIBED)","name":"request_supported","passed":true},{"detail":"PayPal capture status is COMPLETED","name":"payment_captured","passed":true},{"detail":"Purchased 0 days ago; window is 30 days","name":"return_window","passed":true},{"detail":"Trail Runner sneakers, EU size 42 is eligible for return","name":"product_eligible","passed":true},{"detail":"Requested 49.99 USD; refundable 49.99 USD","name":"refundable_amount","passed":true}],"decision":"ELIGIBLE","reasons":[],"stage":"final"},"stage":"policy","title":"Policy final: ELIGIBLE — return for a refund (supplier not involved)"}},{"seq":11,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:26Z","prev_hash":"364e45e6d42212cb92faa6324e33d458db2c67b167ed8db1ad7e8d287f8c931a","entry_hash":"01fc392c109c04e6045eec44e68cd1a888befdaa3c4b61ddedc005067a7a0010","payload":{"decision":"ELIGIBLE","status":"PENDING_APPROVAL"}},{"seq":12,"type":"audit:human","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:26Z","prev_hash":"01fc392c109c04e6045eec44e68cd1a888befdaa3c4b61ddedc005067a7a0010","entry_hash":"fc26df3442f2aaf69effeba0ac72705efd2e3909974119867af3c75988e3b651","payload":{"detail":{"auto_enabled":false,"auto_exchange_enabled":false,"auto_refund_max_amount":"50.00","why":"AUTO_ENABLED is off — every refund needs a person"},"stage":"human","title":"Autonomy: HUMAN — this case needs a person"}},{"seq":13,"type":"audit:note","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:26Z","prev_hash":"fc26df3442f2aaf69effeba0ac72705efd2e3909974119867af3c75988e3b651","entry_hash":"d74a0323d87ddaa1143fa76f0b6c9e80081ce9206a5ded8405b213cd11fdf2dd","payload":{"detail":{"generator":"template","language":"English","language_code":"en","outcome":"PENDING_NOTE","source_en":"Your return request has been reviewed and is awaiting merchant approval. No refund has been issued yet.","text":"Your return request has been reviewed and is awaiting merchant approval. No refund has been issued yet.","validation":"English template."},"stage":"note","title":"Customer note drafted: awaiting merchant approval (not sent)"}},{"seq":14,"type":"audit:human","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:26Z","prev_hash":"d74a0323d87ddaa1143fa76f0b6c9e80081ce9206a5ded8405b213cd11fdf2dd","entry_hash":"ee3011d4b7a5e2a01e953ea6cf62a90dc661c6c3546af7a5fe69d91c9c5c141d","payload":{"detail":{"amount":"49.99 USD"},"stage":"human","title":"Waiting for human approval of the refund"}},{"seq":15,"type":"paypal:get_capture","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:27Z","prev_hash":"ee3011d4b7a5e2a01e953ea6cf62a90dc661c6c3546af7a5fe69d91c9c5c141d","entry_hash":"df2a09ca1f6a93ecfbc84dfc61a7320c17d543ed776d7a8346256266e2697b6d","payload":{"debug_id":"f569700d2faf2","evidence":{"amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"id":"9M172932W5856520H","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"get_capture","request_id":null,"result":"{\"id\": \"9M172932W5856520H\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":16,"type":"audit:policy","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:27Z","prev_hash":"df2a09ca1f6a93ecfbc84dfc61a7320c17d543ed776d7a8346256266e2697b6d","entry_hash":"af525965faeec9d532579b9181dc03ae63a668232bad0ff97413bcc1e0ce725a","payload":{"detail":{"action":"REFUND","capture_id":"9M172932W5856520H","capture_status":"COMPLETED","checks":[{"detail":"Request understood as REFUND_REQUEST / REFUND (reason NOT_AS_DESCRIBED)","name":"request_supported","passed":true},{"detail":"PayPal capture status is COMPLETED","name":"payment_captured","passed":true},{"detail":"Purchased 0 days ago; window is 30 days","name":"return_window","passed":true},{"detail":"Trail Runner sneakers, EU size 42 is eligible for return","name":"product_eligible","passed":true},{"detail":"Requested 49.99 USD; refundable 49.99 USD","name":"refundable_amount","passed":true}],"decision":"ELIGIBLE","reasons":[],"stage":"final"},"stage":"policy","title":"Policy re-check before refund: ELIGIBLE"}},{"seq":17,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:27Z","prev_hash":"af525965faeec9d532579b9181dc03ae63a668232bad0ff97413bcc1e0ce725a","entry_hash":"794a0a5603478564c6282f12b434eb1fdc0f640cc8cf78d5842adf2b76cf8770","payload":{"approval_source":"human","human_decision":"APPROVED"}},{"seq":18,"type":"audit:human","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:27Z","prev_hash":"794a0a5603478564c6282f12b434eb1fdc0f640cc8cf78d5842adf2b76cf8770","entry_hash":"8129b91bd6cfd24ba7bd3df0d6ce088ce1dfca7fe7f86470e2cd31375ff8bbfb","payload":{"detail":{"approver":"merchant","source":"human"},"stage":"human","title":"Human approved the refund"}},{"seq":19,"type":"audit:note","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:27Z","prev_hash":"8129b91bd6cfd24ba7bd3df0d6ce088ce1dfca7fe7f86470e2cd31375ff8bbfb","entry_hash":"100913a6f7be4f1fc434d1013395feae800e437920ee3c42f7edac8aa9f2e9ea","payload":{"detail":{"generator":"template","language":"English","language_code":"en","outcome":"REFUND_NOTE","source_en":"This refund of 49.99 USD is for your returned item. Thank you for your patience!","text":"This refund of 49.99 USD is for your returned item. Thank you for your patience!","validation":"English template."},"stage":"note","title":"note_to_payer written for the refund call (neutral wording)"}},{"seq":20,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:27Z","prev_hash":"100913a6f7be4f1fc434d1013395feae800e437920ee3c42f7edac8aa9f2e9ea","entry_hash":"92a99e2d572d7ee8261976fba26c7e91e96a9e6f070605574d26d95bc8182534","payload":{"refund_request_id":"tradeos-refund-F-089279C5C8904354","status":"REFUND_OUTCOME_UNKNOWN"}},{"seq":21,"type":"paypal:refund_capture","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:29Z","prev_hash":"92a99e2d572d7ee8261976fba26c7e91e96a9e6f070605574d26d95bc8182534","entry_hash":"071b1f4788ecad8caaa189ff0a3643373dd0794e39db9f37653d797ddf066742","payload":{"debug_id":"f56970058bdcc","evidence":{"amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"id":"1LF75336ME8988949","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"refund_capture","request_id":"tradeos-refund-F-089279C5C8904354","result":"{\"id\": \"1LF75336ME8988949\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":22,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:29Z","prev_hash":"071b1f4788ecad8caaa189ff0a3643373dd0794e39db9f37653d797ddf066742","entry_hash":"02052b546db274862df110b2bcb8f101a20ef7334754141b390c41546bdf71b7","payload":{"refund_id":"1LF75336ME8988949","refund_status":"COMPLETED","status":"REFUND_COMPLETED"}},{"seq":23,"type":"audit:paypal","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:29Z","prev_hash":"02052b546db274862df110b2bcb8f101a20ef7334754141b390c41546bdf71b7","entry_hash":"fdbaf7a8eb66a227e490dfbcd2f70d4ecc00cd7538c35face15bcd0d3a73f371","payload":{"detail":{"amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"amount_verified":true,"create_time":"2026-11-09T02:43:28-08:00","expected_amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"note_to_payer":"This refund of 49.99 USD is for your returned item. Thank you for your patience!","paypal_request_id":"tradeos-refund-F-089279C5C8904354","refund_id":"1LF75336ME8988949","status":"COMPLETED","status_details":null},"stage":"paypal","title":"PayPal refund COMPLETED"}},{"seq":24,"type":"audit:note","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:29Z","prev_hash":"fdbaf7a8eb66a227e490dfbcd2f70d4ecc00cd7538c35face15bcd0d3a73f371","entry_hash":"bb4f525b9860be13df19a12b9b51cbb172861305d54630f11b07916c2f1d2c66","payload":{"detail":{"generator":"template","language":"English","language_code":"en","outcome":"COMPLETED_NOTE","source_en":"Your return was approved and your refund of 49.99 USD has been completed by PayPal. Thank you!","text":"Your return was approved and your refund of 49.99 USD has been completed by PayPal. Thank you!","validation":"English template."},"stage":"note","title":"Final customer note written after PayPal COMPLETED"}},{"seq":25,"type":"webhook:received","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:46Z","prev_hash":"bb4f525b9860be13df19a12b9b51cbb172861305d54630f11b07916c2f1d2c66","entry_hash":"4813a2ec3438080c8920ff562f5913d60fd9b153d3b004216891b108075eb306","payload":{"event_id":"WH-06A75520SG4506712-8HR814593V2024800","event_type":"PAYMENT.CAPTURE.REFUNDED","outcome":"PROCESSING","resource_id":"1LF75336ME8988949","resource_status":"COMPLETED","verification":"SUCCESS","verified":true,"verify_method":"self"}},{"seq":26,"type":"webhook:outcome","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:46Z","prev_hash":"4813a2ec3438080c8920ff562f5913d60fd9b153d3b004216891b108075eb306","entry_hash":"e11fc12e5bb883c86a1394ee1e7d4a4012996ff8bafa6f19b03e892878c688c6","payload":{"event_id":"WH-06A75520SG4506712-8HR814593V2024800","event_type":"PAYMENT.CAPTURE.REFUNDED","outcome":"CONFIRMED","resource_id":"1LF75336ME8988949","resource_status":"COMPLETED","verification":"SUCCESS","verified":true,"verify_method":"self"}},{"seq":27,"type":"audit:webhook","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:46Z","prev_hash":"e11fc12e5bb883c86a1394ee1e7d4a4012996ff8bafa6f19b03e892878c688c6","entry_hash":"dc9016661920b0bb422bfb74758ecd6a4ad42d06af3be46d9e01be09120d77c7","payload":{"detail":{"create_time":"2026-11-09T10:43:32.569Z","event_id":"WH-06A75520SG4506712-8HR814593V2024800","event_type":"PAYMENT.CAPTURE.REFUNDED","received_at":"2026-11-09T10:43:46Z","resource_id":"1LF75336ME8988949","resource_status":"COMPLETED","status_details":null,"transmission_age":"fresh","transmission_time":"2026-11-09T10:43:44Z","verification":"SUCCESS","verify_method":"self"},"stage":"webhook","title":"PayPal webhook PAYMENT.CAPTURE.REFUNDED received — signature verified (second confirmation)"}},{"seq":28,"type":"paypal:get_capture","ts":"2026-11-09T10:46:09Z","prev_hash":"dc9016661920b0bb422bfb74758ecd6a4ad42d06af3be46d9e01be09120d77c7","entry_hash":"582d4e0fd01223eb120008667dc9d32251458d52581420a3e2050cb3c6ae8a61","payload":{"debug_id":"f528765b88f11","evidence":{"amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"id":"9M172932W5856520H","status":"REFUNDED"},"ok":true,"operation":"get_capture","request_id":null,"result":"{\"id\": \"9M172932W5856520H\", \"status\": \"REFUNDED\"}"}},{"seq":29,"type":"paypal:get_refund","ts":"2026-11-09T10:46:10Z","prev_hash":"582d4e0fd01223eb120008667dc9d32251458d52581420a3e2050cb3c6ae8a61","entry_hash":"9cacf1e8dccfda4d2a74f539054f767ffe94138cee1c5de75002cca7f1585694","payload":{"debug_id":"f528765e809ff","evidence":{"amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"id":"1LF75336ME8988949","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"get_refund","request_id":null,"result":"{\"id\": \"1LF75336ME8988949\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":30,"type":"audit:reconcile","ts":"2026-11-09T10:46:10Z","prev_hash":"9cacf1e8dccfda4d2a74f539054f767ffe94138cee1c5de75002cca7f1585694","entry_hash":"1abac4b13c6a41126bb5194afa0d8463878a12bc131a54f25d2dd1b595ee9436","payload":{"detail":{"checks":[{"field":"capture.status","local":"PARTIALLY_REFUNDED/REFUNDED","match":true,"paypal":"REFUNDED"},{"field":"capture.amount","local":"49.99 USD","match":true,"paypal":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"}},{"advanced":false,"field":"refund.status","local":"COMPLETED","match":true,"paypal":"COMPLETED"},{"field":"refund.amount","local":"49.99 USD","match":true,"paypal":"49.99 USD"}],"needs_human":null,"ok":true,"seq":1794221170523803788},"stage":"reconcile","title":"Reconciled with PayPal — all match"}}],"paypal_calls":[{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:25Z","operation":"create_order_with_card","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"7S142334X2468105D\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f547983f3dfd5","request_id":"tradeos-order-F-089279C5C8904354"},{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:26Z","operation":"get_capture","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"9M172932W5856520H\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f194143afc9c4","request_id":null},{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:27Z","operation":"get_capture","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"9M172932W5856520H\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f569700d2faf2","request_id":null},{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:29Z","operation":"refund_capture","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"1LF75336ME8988949\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f56970058bdcc","request_id":"tradeos-refund-F-089279C5C8904354"},{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:46:09Z","operation":"get_capture","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"9M172932W5856520H\", \"status\": \"REFUNDED\"}","debug_id":"f528765b88f11","request_id":null},{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:46:10Z","operation":"get_refund","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"1LF75336ME8988949\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f528765e809ff","request_id":null}],"how_to_verify":"entry_hash = sha256(canonical_json({case_id, seq, type, ts, payload, prev_hash})); canonical_json = sorted keys, separators (',', ':'), UTF-8, ensure_ascii=False; entry 1 has prev_hash = 64 zeros. Record chain_head somewhere outside this server: tamper-evident, not tamper-proof."}