{"report":"TradeOS case evidence","generated_at":"2026-11-16T15:56:32Z","case_id":"F-9DAA5900C4FC43A8","environment":{"paypal_mode":"sandbox","note":"PayPal Sandbox only — no real money"},"summary":{"status":"EXCHANGE_ARRANGED","decision":"EXCHANGE_ELIGIBLE","human_decision":"APPROVED","approval_source":"human","refund_status":null},"paypal_ids":{"order_id":"3178557622278761J","capture_id":"76G87226E6305412H"},"refund_batches":[],"refund_api_called":false,"verification":{"ok":true,"case_id":"F-9DAA5900C4FC43A8","entries":20,"broken_at":null,"reason":null,"head":"ecc090fd83795a0ceb10d23bdd1c80f765e92271c481467aaad4b716eee3aeed","backfilled":0},"chain_head":"ecc090fd83795a0ceb10d23bdd1c80f765e92271c481467aaad4b716eee3aeed","chain_entries":[{"seq":1,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:05Z","prev_hash":"0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000","entry_hash":"c51d07026e4fa87cd86356ff7e3e9ca8182b93e6a18d984bb3ccd701af6c4145","payload":{"status":"NEW"}},{"seq":2,"type":"paypal:create_order_with_card","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:09Z","prev_hash":"c51d07026e4fa87cd86356ff7e3e9ca8182b93e6a18d984bb3ccd701af6c4145","entry_hash":"e50063f56c58e72bd13f7e27cbf2ef0fd43239b49535ba24cdbf31ac0ecf1d06","payload":{"debug_id":"f26410583f8d7","evidence":{"capture_id":"76G87226E6305412H","capture_status":"COMPLETED","id":"3178557622278761J","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"create_order_with_card","request_id":"tradeos-order-F-9DAA5900C4FC43A8","result":"{\"id\": \"3178557622278761J\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":3,"type":"audit:payment","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:09Z","prev_hash":"e50063f56c58e72bd13f7e27cbf2ef0fd43239b49535ba24cdbf31ac0ecf1d06","entry_hash":"9429c38cd98ce0463b582e30e2cba9e68c62562b03c7250698b461cd5f48658e","payload":{"detail":{"amount":"49.99 USD","order_id":"3178557622278761J","status":"COMPLETED"},"stage":"payment","title":"PayPal order created"}},{"seq":4,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:09Z","prev_hash":"9429c38cd98ce0463b582e30e2cba9e68c62562b03c7250698b461cd5f48658e","entry_hash":"36cc139f977022158fd557a92673239dc1401b5f627cb560425e92df036b7bf1","payload":{"capture_id":"76G87226E6305412H"}},{"seq":5,"type":"audit:payment","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:09Z","prev_hash":"36cc139f977022158fd557a92673239dc1401b5f627cb560425e92df036b7bf1","entry_hash":"b099c2a56a11569d95496cc005c3ba35b3635fe406683fcb0fb03241dc5824ba","payload":{"detail":{"capture_id":"76G87226E6305412H","order_id":"3178557622278761J","status":"COMPLETED"},"stage":"payment","title":"PayPal payment captured"}},{"seq":6,"type":"audit:request","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:09Z","prev_hash":"b099c2a56a11569d95496cc005c3ba35b3635fe406683fcb0fb03241dc5824ba","entry_hash":"2b2dd130f86827da6ea436b3a8f47e8aead38c04e6549952d36286c0e9044206","payload":{"detail":{"customer":"Free-text customer","message":"The shoes are too small. Can I exchange size 42 for size 43?"},"stage":"request","title":"Customer request received"}},{"seq":7,"type":"audit:intent","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:09Z","prev_hash":"2b2dd130f86827da6ea436b3a8f47e8aead38c04e6549952d36286c0e9044206","entry_hash":"c63f746109dd6720f33c69dbf2c82455af378a82b043f03cee7f06cdad4ee583","payload":{"detail":{"assist":{"current_size":"42","language":"English","language_code":"en","merchant_summary_en":"Customer wants to exchange shoes from size 42 to size 43 due to size too small.","requested_size":"43"},"assist_note":"Validated (information only; the policy engine ignores these fields).","extractor":"llm:openai/gpt-oss-20b","intent":"EXCHANGE_REQUEST","note":"Validated against strict schema.","reason":"SIZE_MISMATCH","requested_action":"EXCHANGE","safety_gate":{"flagged":false,"rule_version":"safety-gate/3.4.0-main"}},"stage":"intent","title":"Intent extracted"}},{"seq":8,"type":"paypal:get_capture","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"c63f746109dd6720f33c69dbf2c82455af378a82b043f03cee7f06cdad4ee583","entry_hash":"d1525ba16e66e0a2f252c784d66c64d2ceb894237f8ceb60b483e0e7d0b74dc5","payload":{"debug_id":"f1152937feada","evidence":{"amount":{"currency_code":"USD","value":"49.99"},"id":"76G87226E6305412H","status":"COMPLETED"},"ok":true,"operation":"get_capture","request_id":null,"result":"{\"id\": \"76G87226E6305412H\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}"}},{"seq":9,"type":"audit:policy","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"d1525ba16e66e0a2f252c784d66c64d2ceb894237f8ceb60b483e0e7d0b74dc5","entry_hash":"6eb368ff99b39daf619f49732a4f3a78b65cc75c9c83f752ab09130fbcc5e48a","payload":{"detail":{"action":"EXCHANGE","checks":[{"detail":"Request understood as EXCHANGE_REQUEST / EXCHANGE (reason SIZE_MISMATCH)","name":"request_supported","passed":true},{"detail":"PayPal capture status is COMPLETED","name":"payment_captured","passed":true},{"detail":"Purchased 0 days ago; window is 30 days","name":"return_window","passed":true},{"detail":"Trail Runner sneakers, EU size 42 is eligible for exchange","name":"product_eligible","passed":true}],"decision":"ELIGIBLE","reasons":[],"stage":"pre-supplier"},"stage":"policy","title":"Policy pre-check: ELIGIBLE"}},{"seq":10,"type":"audit:supplier","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"6eb368ff99b39daf619f49732a4f3a78b65cc75c9c83f752ab09130fbcc5e48a","entry_hash":"9491575315f8e4013d6dc5177b2841113804cf302e98b51c0bb07f6d9808c468","payload":{"detail":{"draft":"To: Stride Footwear Co. (fictional demo supplier)\nSubject: Replacement request — order 3178557622278761J (Trail Runner sneakers, EU size 42)\n\nHello,\n\nOur customer Free-text customer has requested an exchange (reason: size mismatch).\nCustomer message: \"The shoes are too small. Can I exchange size 42 for size 43?\"\n\nProduct: Trail Runner sneakers, EU size 42 (SKU TRAIL-RUNNER-42)\nPlease confirm you can ship a replacement in the requested size.\n\nReference: TradeOS case F-9DAA5900C4FC43A8\nThank you."},"stage":"supplier","title":"Supplier draft generated"}},{"seq":11,"type":"audit:supplier","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"9491575315f8e4013d6dc5177b2841113804cf302e98b51c0bb07f6d9808c468","entry_hash":"3a9c9d853fe7eab4a2fd027b8033d0f4bddbb450d759ec650fecd7efc99bfa3e","payload":{"detail":{"is_mock":true,"label":"MOCK supplier reply — simulated for the demo, not a real supplier","message":"Replacement approved for case F-9DAA5900C4FC43A8. New size will ship within 3 business days.","status":"REPLACEMENT_APPROVED"},"stage":"supplier","title":"Supplier replied: REPLACEMENT_APPROVED (MOCK)"}},{"seq":12,"type":"audit:policy","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"3a9c9d853fe7eab4a2fd027b8033d0f4bddbb450d759ec650fecd7efc99bfa3e","entry_hash":"3989eaef84eb1ae53f1d6a350445284dc5404c96e37aea3798393aca328257d6","payload":{"detail":{"action":"EXCHANGE","checks":[{"detail":"Request understood as EXCHANGE_REQUEST / EXCHANGE (reason SIZE_MISMATCH)","name":"request_supported","passed":true},{"detail":"PayPal capture status is COMPLETED","name":"payment_captured","passed":true},{"detail":"Purchased 0 days ago; window is 30 days","name":"return_window","passed":true},{"detail":"Trail Runner sneakers, EU size 42 is eligible for exchange","name":"product_eligible","passed":true},{"detail":"Supplier status: REPLACEMENT_APPROVED","name":"supplier_confirmed","passed":true}],"decision":"ELIGIBLE","reasons":[],"stage":"final"},"stage":"policy","title":"Policy final: ELIGIBLE"}},{"seq":13,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"3989eaef84eb1ae53f1d6a350445284dc5404c96e37aea3798393aca328257d6","entry_hash":"3f17bbd390ceeed4fe445f2fff57817895a6a334cd53336280e0541024ba67a6","payload":{"decision":"EXCHANGE_ELIGIBLE","status":"PENDING_APPROVAL"}},{"seq":14,"type":"audit:human","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"3f17bbd390ceeed4fe445f2fff57817895a6a334cd53336280e0541024ba67a6","entry_hash":"7083979d1b97bf1ce76a0fa7ab031e7e26603c811f42d11a6e961a12ef5146e0","payload":{"detail":{"auto_enabled":false,"auto_exchange_enabled":false,"auto_refund_max_amount":"50.00","why":"AUTO_ENABLED is off — every refund needs a person"},"stage":"human","title":"Autonomy: HUMAN — this case needs a person"}},{"seq":15,"type":"audit:note","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"7083979d1b97bf1ce76a0fa7ab031e7e26603c811f42d11a6e961a12ef5146e0","entry_hash":"097c25a2096f7183297ecc2418200862b44cf38f5b70b6c0442575e1e8377f56","payload":{"detail":{"generator":"template","language":"English","language_code":"en","outcome":"PENDING_NOTE","source_en":"Your exchange request (size 42 → 43) has been reviewed and is awaiting merchant approval. No refund is involved in an exchange.","text":"Your exchange request (size 42 → 43) has been reviewed and is awaiting merchant approval. No refund is involved in an exchange.","validation":"English template."},"stage":"note","title":"Customer note drafted: awaiting merchant approval (not sent)"}},{"seq":16,"type":"audit:human","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","prev_hash":"097c25a2096f7183297ecc2418200862b44cf38f5b70b6c0442575e1e8377f56","entry_hash":"d3aed703a66cb7c2720e1c84395c0f50263c8bdda57550886c00ec5d9f180d0d","payload":{"detail":{"refund":"none — exchange"},"stage":"human","title":"Waiting for human approval of the exchange (no refund)"}},{"seq":17,"type":"case:update","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:11Z","prev_hash":"d3aed703a66cb7c2720e1c84395c0f50263c8bdda57550886c00ec5d9f180d0d","entry_hash":"3300c978df3a6e1486f920fb0f66c5013a0f4b05aee6881ce8b4da6db0c2fa81","payload":{"approval_source":"human","human_decision":"APPROVED","status":"EXCHANGE_ARRANGED"}},{"seq":18,"type":"audit:human","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:11Z","prev_hash":"3300c978df3a6e1486f920fb0f66c5013a0f4b05aee6881ce8b4da6db0c2fa81","entry_hash":"e48d7b77c006bbf926f9bd8cb30bd8e4b87ca510576eb93ce5bd0ef2fad27219","payload":{"detail":{"approver":"merchant","source":"human"},"stage":"human","title":"Human approved the exchange"}},{"seq":19,"type":"audit:paypal","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:11Z","prev_hash":"e48d7b77c006bbf926f9bd8cb30bd8e4b87ca510576eb93ce5bd0ef2fad27219","entry_hash":"2a5ee3b29a397b183694f3348ac49bf8a9bed9f66e08937a6ca4e529cba5114b","payload":{"detail":{"refund_id":null},"stage":"paypal","title":"Refund API NOT CALLED — exchange arranged (replacement via the MOCK supplier), no refund"}},{"seq":20,"type":"audit:note","ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:11Z","prev_hash":"2a5ee3b29a397b183694f3348ac49bf8a9bed9f66e08937a6ca4e529cba5114b","entry_hash":"ecc090fd83795a0ceb10d23bdd1c80f765e92271c481467aaad4b716eee3aeed","payload":{"detail":{"generator":"template","language":"English","language_code":"en","outcome":"EXCHANGE_NOTE","source_en":"Your exchange request (size 42 → 43) was approved. The replacement is being arranged with our supplier; no refund is involved. Thank you!","text":"Your exchange request (size 42 → 43) was approved. The replacement is being arranged with our supplier; no refund is involved. Thank you!","validation":"English template."},"stage":"note","title":"Customer note written after the human approved the exchange (no refund)"}}],"paypal_calls":[{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:09Z","operation":"create_order_with_card","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"3178557622278761J\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f26410583f8d7","request_id":"tradeos-order-F-9DAA5900C4FC43A8"},{"ts":"2026-11-09T10:43:10Z","operation":"get_capture","ok":1,"result":"{\"id\": \"76G87226E6305412H\", \"status\": \"COMPLETED\"}","debug_id":"f1152937feada","request_id":null}],"how_to_verify":"entry_hash = sha256(canonical_json({case_id, seq, type, ts, payload, prev_hash})); canonical_json = sorted keys, separators (',', ':'), UTF-8, ensure_ascii=False; entry 1 has prev_hash = 64 zeros. Record chain_head somewhere outside this server: tamper-evident, not tamper-proof."}